Mental contrasting is an exercise developed by psychologist Gabriele Oettingen: you imagine what you want and the best that would come of it, then you look squarely at the inner obstacle that could stop you. The WOOP method adds a fourth step, a plan in the form “if this happens, then I will do that.” It takes a few minutes, with pen and paper. It promises nothing: it helps you move with more determination, and figure out when a wish needs rethinking.
Here you will find what the studies say, why the imagined goal alone is not enough, and where the Way uses the same move every day. The studies cited here are about motivation and goals, not about Via Auctoris: the connections with the Way are our own reading.
Why isn’t visualizing your goal enough?
One possible explanation: the imagined goal feels good right away, and that pleasure can arrive in place of the drive.
Gabriele Oettingen, a professor of psychology at New York University and the University of Hamburg, has spent years studying positive fantasies about the future. In a paper she wrote with Heather Barry Kappes, the title already states the conclusion: positive fantasies about an idealized future sap energy. In those experiments, people who fantasized positively about the future went on to show less energy.
It is not a condemnation of dreaming. The wish remains the starting point. The problem arises when the picture ends there. For the Way, it is the same reason classic manifesting stops halfway, as What Is Manifesting, Really? What Works and What Doesn’t explains.
What is mental contrasting?
It is the step the dream is missing: placing beside the image of the goal the reality that separates us from it.
Here is how it works. First you imagine the best outcome, calmly, in detail. Right after, you ask yourself what, inside you, could stop you: a habit, an emotion, a thought that keeps coming back. Not outside circumstances, but the part you can govern.
The contrast between the two images does something useful: if the wish is attainable, it gives you a reason to move; if it is not, it helps you realize that in time.
How does the WOOP method work?
WOOP is the name Oettingen gave the exercise to make it easy to remember. It is the initials of four words.
- Wish. Something you want, challenging but possible.
- Outcome. The best benefit that would come of it. You really imagine it, for a few moments.
- Obstacle. The main inner obstacle. You imagine this too, in the moment it shows up.
- Plan. A sentence that links the obstacle to an action: “When this comes up, then I do that.”
Order matters. First the outcome, then the obstacle: it is the contrast that creates the drive.
What are if-then plans?
The last step of WOOP draws on another line of research, that of Peter Gollwitzer, a psychologist and Oettingen’s collaborator. His implementation intentions are plans that link a specific situation to a specific response: “if situation X arises, then I will do Y.”
The advantage is that the decision has already been made. When the obstacle comes, you do not have to negotiate with tiredness or with the urge to put things off: you just have to carry out what you wrote.
Where does the Way practice mental contrasting?
In the Obstacle Mirror, one of the daily practices. After the Dawn Rite, or before the day’s action, you reread the intention, choose the inner obstacle that could stop you today, and put it into one sentence: “When… then…”. Then, for half a minute, you imagine the scene in which the obstacle arrives and you respond as you had decided.
For the Way, it is how you give strength to the Act. In the triangle of the Triad, Thought knows what you want, Feeling knows what it would be like to have it, the Act carries it into the world. The obstacle looked at in advance keeps the Act’s road open right at the moment when it would be easiest to let it go.
What mental contrasting is not
It is not pessimism. You look at the obstacle to get past it, not to talk yourself into giving up.
It is not about controlling everything. Outside circumstances, other people’s choices, the unexpected stay outside. You work on what depends on you.
It is not a sure thing. No exercise can promise a result. It can make it more likely that you do your part, and sometimes it can tell you, honestly, that the wish needs to be rewritten.
Melissa is forty-one, and for a year she has been saying that her apartment building could use a little book-swap library in the lobby. She pictures the shelf full and the neighbors stopping to chat, and every time it feels as good as done. The lobby, meanwhile, is as empty as before. One evening she tries WOOP on a sheet of paper. Wish: “At the end of this Cycle there is a shelf with thirty books in the lobby, and I have talked about it with every family in the building.” Outcome: knowing the people who live above and below her by name. Obstacle: when she runs into a neighbor on the stairs, she thinks “I’m bothering them” and just says hello. Plan: “When I run into a neighbor on the stairs, then I stop and tell them about the shelf in one sentence.” She does not know yet how many books will arrive. She knows what she will say to the first neighbor she meets.
Three minutes, twelve questions. Find out which threshold you are on and get your first Dawn Rite.
In practice
Five minutes, a sheet of paper folded into quarters.
- In the first box, write a wish for the next few weeks, challenging but possible.
- In the second, the best outcome that would come of it. Close your eyes and see it for a few seconds.
- In the third, the obstacle that lies inside you. Imagine the precise moment it shows up.
- In the fourth, a single sentence: “When [obstacle], then [action].”
- For half a minute, see the scene: the obstacle shows up and you respond as you wrote.
Keep the sheet where you will see it tomorrow morning. It resembles the Obstacle Mirror, which on the Way is repeated every day: the Obstacle Mirror page explains it step by step.
If you want to know which of the three sides tends to give way first for you, the Test of the Way shows you your weak side in three minutes.
Questions
What is the WOOP method, in short?
It is a four-step exercise proposed by Gabriele Oettingen: a wish, the best outcome, the inner obstacle, a plan. The name comes from the initials of four words: Wish, Outcome, Obstacle, Plan.
Can you give me a WOOP example?
Wish: clear out the garage. Outcome: park the car in it again. Obstacle: the urge to put it off until the following Saturday. Plan: when I finish breakfast on Saturday, then I carry out three boxes.
What are if-then plans?
They are decisions made in advance in the form “if this happens, then I will do that.” Peter Gollwitzer called them implementation intentions: they tie a specific moment to a specific action.
Will mental contrasting get me what I want?
No. It helps you figure out whether a wish is within your reach and move with more determination. The outcome also depends on other people, on time and on the unexpected.
Sources
- Gabriele Oettingen, Rethinking Positive Thinking: Inside the New Science of Motivation
- Heather Barry Kappes, Gabriele Oettingen, Positive fantasies about idealized futures sap energy
- Peter M. Gollwitzer, Implementation intentions: Strong effects of simple plans
Three minutes, twelve questions. Find out which threshold you are on and get your first Dawn Rite.
The text that gathers the Beliefs, the Three Laws and the first 21 days of practice. You can read it in a weekend. It walks with you for the rest of the path.
Written by Via Auctoris Editorial Team.



