Skip to content
A lodestone on a stone table, with iron filings arranged in curved lines around it; behind it, scrolls and maps in half-light.

Does the Law of Attraction Work? An Honest Look

Does the law of attraction work? Partly yes, partly no. What is true, what does not hold up, and what the Way adds to it, starting with the Act.

Via Auctoris Editorial Team · · 7 min read · How we work

Does the law of attraction work? Partly yes and partly no. The idea that what you pay attention to changes what you notice, and therefore what you do, holds up. The idea that thought, on its own, attracts events does not hold up, much less the idea that people who suffer have “attracted” their pain. In between lies what the law of attraction leaves out: the Act.

It is the same question our guide to manifesting, explained honestly starts from. Here we look in detail at the law that sits underneath it.

What is the law of attraction, and what does it claim?

In short: like attracts like. Thoughts and emotions are supposed to work like magnets. If you think and feel as if your wish had already come true, that wish draws closer; if you think about lack, you attract more lack.

The idea was born in the nineteenth century, in the American New Thought movement, and it returns in many twentieth-century books. Since then the practice has almost always stressed two steps: getting clear on the wish and feeling it as true. There is a lot of good in them. What comes next, the doing, is often left unspoken: that is where the road breaks off.

What’s true about the law of attraction?

More than its harshest critics think.

You know it from experience. The day you decide to buy a yellow bicycle, you see them everywhere on the street. There are not more of them: they have entered your line of sight. Attention is selective, and a clear wish gives it a target.

This also changes what you do. A person who notices an opportunity can take it; a person who does not notice it has nothing to take. Seen from the outside, it looks as if the person “attracted” something. Seen from the inside, they looked more closely and made a move.

The Way calls this gaze the Observer, and places it inside a specific Belief, the Field: choose where to look, and accept that not everything depends on you.

What doesn’t hold up: criticisms of the law of attraction

There are three best-known criticisms: there is no evidence, people only remember the times it worked, and it ends up blaming those who suffer.

Attracting events with thought alone. There is no evidence that a thought, however intense, brings a person, a job or a sum of money your way. When something arrives, it has usually come through actions, encounters, choices, even tiny ones. And there is another reason it seems to work: we remember the times a wish came true and forget all the others.

The idea that people who suffer “brought it on themselves.” This is the harshest consequence of the law of attraction taken literally. If thought creates reality, then an illness, a loss, a layoff would be the fault of the person living through it. The Way rejects this idea without hesitation, and it wrote that rejection into the last line of its Manifesto:

“And we believe that no one should feel guilty for the pain they have lived through. The Field does not punish: it walks with those who choose.”

Belief VII · Protection covers it in full.

If you are going through a hard time

The Way is a path of personal growth, not a medical or psychological service. If you are not well, talk to your doctor or a psychologist. If you are in danger, or someone close to you is, call your local emergency number (911 in the US, 999 in the UK, 112 in Europe) right away. Asking for help is an Author’s act, perhaps the most important one.

The authors of the books on the law of attraction helped many people stop and ask themselves what they really want. Those books are missing a side, not good faith.

What does the Way add to the law of attraction?

Four things, in this order of importance.

First of all, the Act. Thought and Feeling prepare the ground, but the Act is the side that carries the intention outside of you. Every day, one concrete action toward what you have chosen, as small as it needs to be for you to do it even on bad days. It is the missing side of the law of attraction.

The obstacle. Many texts on the law of attraction encourage you not to dwell on what could go wrong. Gabriele Oettingen, studying positive fantasies, observed the opposite: imagining only the finish line can drain energy, while looking at the inner obstacle right after helps you get moving. The Way practices this every day.

The Season. Between the seed and the fruit there is a time you cannot see. A delay is not a refusal, as long as the actions continue. The Way also gives you a way to tell good waiting from waiting that is only giving up: it is explained on the Season page.

Protection. The Field does not punish. What is out of your hands, other people, time, the unexpected, is not your failure. What is left to you is your response.

Imaginary example

Lisa, 47, would like to find her way back to her son Tyler, who at fifteen has shut himself away in his room. For weeks she repeats every morning: “My son talks to me.” Then she waits, and nothing happens. One day she realizes the sentence depends on him, not on her. She rewrites it: “Every evening I spend ten minutes in the room where he is, without my phone.” Her first action is to sit in the kitchen while he eats. On the third day she notices something that had always escaped her: at night, quietly, Tyler plays the guitar. On Friday she asks to hear a song. He says no. On Sunday he plays one from his bedroom doorway, without looking at her. That evening, Lisa writes it in her Journal, under Signs.

The Test of the Way

Three minutes, twelve questions. Find out which threshold you are on and get your first Dawn Rite.

→ Take the Test of the Way

In practice

Five minutes, now or tonight.

  1. Take the wish you think about most these days.
  2. Ask yourself: what can I do myself, without waiting for anyone? Rewrite it that way.
  3. Find the smallest action that brings you closer, one you can do in two minutes: open a document, send a couple of lines, set out your shoes.
  4. Give it a precise time tomorrow and write it down.

That action is your first Act of Alignment, the practice the Way uses to train the third side. The Act of Alignment page explains how to choose it, and what does not count as an Act.

If you do not know which of the three sides you neglect most, the Test of the Way shows you in three minutes.

Questions

Is the law of attraction scientific?

No, not as a law: no evidence shows that a thought attracts an event. What is solid, on the other hand, is the idea that attention changes what you notice and, as a result, what you do.

Why does it sometimes seem to work?

Because people with a clear wish notice more opportunities and sometimes take them. And because we remember the times something arrived far more than the times nothing arrived at all.

If something bad happens to me, did I attract it?

No. Pain is not the result of a wrong thought. If you are going through a hard time, a doctor or a psychologist can help you; in an emergency, call your local emergency number (911 in the US, 999 in the UK, 112 in Europe).

Is the Way the law of attraction?

It keeps the good insight, that what you focus on matters. And it adds, first of all, the Act, then the obstacle, the Season and Protection.

How do you use the law of attraction in practice?

Keep what holds up: choose clearly where to look. Then add what is missing: one concrete action every day, and a plan for the obstacle you expect.

Sources

  • Gabriele Oettingen, Rethinking Positive Thinking: Inside the New Science of Motivation
The Test of the Way

Three minutes, twelve questions. Find out which threshold you are on and get your first Dawn Rite.

→ Take the Test of the Way

From the Founding Book

The text that gathers the Beliefs, the Three Laws and the first 21 days of practice. You can read it in a weekend. It walks with you for the rest of the path.

→ The Founding Book · €17

Written by Via Auctoris Editorial Team.

How we work